7 Seafood Dishes You Have to Try in Bar Harbor, Maine | Geddy’s

Fresh. Local. Legendary.

Maine is a seafood lover’s dream — and Bar Harbor is the heart of it. Cold Atlantic waters, a deep fishing tradition, and bold coastal flavors come together on plates all over town. But at Geddy’s, we take it a step further — using fresh, locally sourced seafood whenever possible and crafting each dish to highlight what makes Maine cuisine so iconic.

If you’re searching for the best seafood in Maine or wondering where to eat in Bar Harbor, explore our full seafood menu and discover why Geddy’s has been a local favorite since 1974.

1. Bar Harbor Lobster Roll

Fresh Maine lobster rolls with crispy fries at Geddy’s in Bar Harbor

The iconic fresh Maine lobster served on a buttery, grilled bun — chilled with a light touch of mayo or served with warm melted butter. Simple, classic, and unforgettable — prepared fresh daily.

It’s the dish most visitors come for — and the one they come back talking about.

2. Steamed Whole Maine Lobster

Maine lobster bake with drawn butter, corn, clam chowder, and blueberry pie at Geddy’s in Bar Harbor

Nothing says “Maine” like cracking into a whole lobster by the harbor. Served with drawn butter and classic coastal sides, this is the full New England experience.

We source directly from local fisherman — because freshness makes all the difference. And if you want to see just how fresh it is, take a look at our live lobster tank — stocked daily. Guests can watch Maine lobsters straight from the Atlantic before they make their way to your table — a true Bar Harbor experience.

3. New England Clam Chowder (a Maine classic)

House-made New England clam chowder with tender clams at Geddy’s Bar Harbor

Creamy, hearty, and packed with flavor. Our New England–style clam chowder is made fresh and loaded with clams, potatoes, and a slight touch of herbs. It’s rich without being heavy — perfect on a foggy, chilly afternoon.

New England clam chowder in Bar Harbor doesn’t get more classic than this.

4. Crispy Calamari

Golden fried calamari at Geddy’s in Bar Harbor, Maine

Lightly breaded and flash-fried, our crispy calamari is tender inside, golden outside, and served with a sweet chili sauce that adds just the right kick. It’s one of the most-loved shareables on the menu — perfect for the table and gone in minutes.

5. Seafood Pasta

Seafood pasta at Geddy’s in Bar Harbor, Maine

This hearty favorite brings together the best of the Atlantic — scallops, lobster, and shrimp tossed with pasta in a flavorful sauce — made-to-order. It’s satisfying without overpowering the delicate sweetness of the seafood.

If you’re looking for something beyond the classics, this is a standout.

6. Atlantic Seafood Pie

Kitchen preparing Geddy’s house-made seafood pie in Bar Harbor, Maine

A true Geddy’s favorite. Our small-batch seafood pie is packed with fresh lobster, shrimp, and scallops in a creamy base topped with seasoned breadcrumbs and baked until golden.

Think comfort food — Maine style.

7. Haddock Fish & Chips

Maine haddock fish and chips served with fries, coleslaw, and house-made tartar sauce at Geddy’s in Bar Harbor

Flaky, mild haddock is the local go-to fish — and it shines in this coastal staple. Lightly battered and served with fries, slaw, and house-made tartar sauce, it’s simple and done right.

Why It Tastes Better Here

At Geddy’s, we don’t just serve seafood — we celebrate it. We work with local fishermen and trusted Maine suppliers who share our commitment to quality and sustainability. From harbor to plate, every step matters.

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
“Best lobster we had in Maine. You can really taste the difference here. Everything tastes like it came straight out of the ocean — because it pretty much did.” – Google review.

Hungry Yet?

Every dish above is served right here at Geddy’s in the heart of Bar Harbor — just steps from the waterfront. It’s the perfect, fun and relaxing stop after a day in Acadia National Park.

📍 Open daily: 11:00am – close
🍽️ Walk-ins welcome, or make reservations
📸 Tag your visit @geddysbarharbor 

Looking for the best seafood in Bar Harbor? Join us at Geddy’s and taste Maine the way it’s meant to be — fresh, local, and legendary.

Come for the lobster. Stay for the view. Leave planning your next visit.

Can’t make it this trip? Grab a Geddy’s gift card.

Bon Appetite from Bar Harbor,
Heather
(Owner)